Film history
The 'Cinema of Unease' and the Different Gazes on New Zealand
Cinema of Unease turned discomfort into a key for reading the country's cinema; Heperi Mita's response reminds us that no single formula can encompass a national history on its own.
In 1995, Sam Neill proposed a reading of New Zealand cinema as a reflection of a society marked by fear, alienation, and violence. This idea gained strength when several local films achieved international visibility, but it did not remain an undisputed definition: Heperi Mita contrasts it with the political perspective of his mother, filmmaker Merata Mita. The disagreement helps understand both the appeal of the 'Cinema of Unease' and the limits of using a single label to describe a diverse cinematography.
A critical thesis tied to a moment of visibility
Cinema of Unease: A Personal Journey by Sam Neill, a one-hour documentary written and co-directed by Neill and Judy Rymer, premiered in 1995 and was part of the BFI's Century of Cinema series. Neill argued that national cinema reflected a troubled society: he linked conformism with fear and read alienation, violence, and the threat of unsettling landscapes in various films.The film appeared when New Zealand works had just gained attention abroad. Jane Campion's The Piano, Peter Jackson's Heavenly Creatures, and Lee Tamahori's Once Were Warriors were examples of that moment. Their international reach helps explain why Neill's proposal resonated, but it does not prove that they shared a single aesthetic or represented the entire local production.
Different films, one interpretive framework
Neill's reading gathered works that addressed different issues and forms. Among the examples he revisits are Roger Donaldson's Sleeping Dogs, a story of political persecution set in a futuristic and authoritarian New Zealand, and Merata Mita's Patu!, a documentary about police violence against those who protested during the 1981 Springboks tour. In those cases, unease can be related to political repression; in other films, such as An Angel at My Table or Braindead, the conflicts pass through personal experience, drama, or horror.That variety makes the label productive as a critical question: what forms of fear or discomfort appear in a film, and what context gives them meaning? But the answer depends on each work. The 'Cinema of Unease' is an interpretation that organizes certain titles, not an automatic property of any New Zealand film.
Heperi Mita's response changes the point of view
Returning to the documentary, Heperi Mita warns that summarizing an entire cinematic history with a single term is a difficult task. He recalls that his mother had described the country's film industry in 1986 as the 'white neurotic film industry'. From his perspective, Neill's later formula was a more romantic and marketable description of something similar, while Merata Mita's gaze started from a political position.They are not two interchangeable phrases. Neill's organizes history around unease and the experience of a young nation; Merata Mita's, as Heperi Mita recalls it, makes visible the political framework from which the industry is judged. Putting them in dialogue does not require choosing one as the definitive explanation: it shows how the same cinematography changes meaning depending on who interprets it and which power relations they consider central.
A national history does not fit into a single formula
The international circulation of Sleeping Dogs, which had wide exhibition abroad, and the external success of films from the early 1990s help situate the influence of Neill's reading. But reaching international audiences does not make a country's production uniform. Nor can a critical idea replace the analysis of specific films or the perspectives of Māori filmmakers, such as Merata Mita.The value of the 'Cinema of Unease' lies, then, in serving as a revisable starting point. It allows recognizing a line of discomfort present in certain works, while leaving open a broader question: what other stories, experiences, and ways of making cinema are left out when national identity is explained with a single word.
Key takeaways
- Cinema of Unease is an interpretation of certain New Zealand films, not an exhaustive definition of the country's entire cinematography.
- Sam Neill's reading gained resonance at a moment of international visibility for several local films.
- Heperi Mita contrasts that reading with the political description of the industry he attributes to his mother, Merata Mita.
- Comparing those perspectives allows asking who defines national cinema and which experiences it brings to the forefront.
Sources and filmography consulted
- The greatest film directors of all time. www.imdb.com. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Which Barrier Was Broken? Broken Barrier and New Zealand Cinema in .... muse.jhu.edu. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Audiovisual collections – archives new zealand. www.archives.govt.nz. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Cinema of Unease: A Personal Journey by Sam Neill. en.wikipedia.org. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- All articles about New Zealand cinema. www.bfi.org.uk. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- 54th Valladolid International Film Festival. www.seminci.com. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- De la reivindicación política al cine comercial de Bollywood. www.metakinema.es. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Film Studies: National Cinemas: New Zealand - Research Guides. researchguides.dartmouth.edu. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- How Sam Neill's 1990s documentary Cinema of Unease reckoned with .... www.bfi.org.uk. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- The World of Movies: Cinema of Unease. www.filmsfatale.com. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Etiquetas: Len Lye. expcinema.org. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- (DOC) Cinema of Unease in History. www.academia.edu. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Film. nzhistory.govt.nz. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- *Mana Waka* screened at the New Zealand International Film Festival in Auckland and Wellington. webarchiveweb.wayback.bac-lac.canada.ca. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Noticias: Festivales de cine - filmmakers - Festhome. filmmakers.festhome.com. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- Out of the Mist: An Alternate History of New Zealand Cinema (2015). mubi.com. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- WIFT NZ Events. www.wiftnz.org.nz. Consulted 12 Nov 2026
- New Zealand Film: An Illustrated History (Web Exclusive). www.cineaste.com. Consulted 12 Nov 2026